Does Switching to an Electric Furnace Save on Utility Costs?

In the realm of home heating, the choice between electric and gas furnaces is often influenced by factors such as initial costs, installation expenses and long-term utility savings.

This May Also Interest You: How Often Should You Change Your Furnace Filter?

Understanding the price differences, installation costs and potential monthly utility savings associated with each type of furnace can help you make smart decisions about your heating system.

Installation Price Comparison: Electric Vs. Gas Furnaces

When considering the price difference between electric and gas furnaces, it's essential to examine both the unit costs and installation expenses. Generally, gas furnaces tend to have lower upfront costs compared to electric furnaces. On average, a gas furnace may cost between $650 to $3,000 for the unit alone, according to WM Buffington Company, while electric furnaces typically range from $700 to $1,100.

However, the disparity in upfront costs is only part of the equation. Installation costs for gas furnaces can be higher due to the need for gas line connections, ventilation systems, and safety measures.

In contrast, electric furnaces are often easier and cheaper to install since they don't require gas lines or exhaust flues. Installation costs for electric furnaces typically range from $2,000 to $4,000, while gas furnace installations can cost up to $5,000, depending on factors such as ductwork requirements and labor fees. If you need to install a gas line, that could add an additional expense of approximately $200 to $500.

Cost of Switching from Gas to Electric

Switching from a gas furnace to an electric one involves not only the cost of the new unit but also the expenses associated with removing the existing gas furnace and installing the electric system. The total cost of this transition can vary significantly based on factors such as the size of the home, existing infrastructure and labor rates.

On average, homeowners can expect to spend anywhere from $2,500 to $10,000 to switch from gas to electric. This includes the cost of purchasing the new electric furnace, removing the old gas furnace, installing the electric unit and any necessary modifications to the home's electrical system.

Monthly Utility Cost Savings

One of the primary considerations for homeowners contemplating a switch to an electric furnace is whether it will lead to savings on monthly utility bills. The answer to this question depends on several factors, including regional energy prices, furnace efficiency ratings and the size and insulation of the home.

In general, electric furnaces tend to be more energy-efficient than gas furnaces, with efficiency ratings ranging from 95% to 100%. Gas furnaces, on the other hand, typically have efficiency ratings between 80% and 98%, depending on the model and installation quality.

While electric furnaces may offer higher efficiency, the cost of electricity varies widely across different regions. In areas where electricity prices are relatively low compared to natural gas rates, homeowners may see significant savings by switching to an electric furnace. However, in regions where electricity prices are high or natural gas is more affordable, the savings may be less pronounced.

More Related Articles:

• Need a New Furnace? Here’s What You Should Know About Costs

• How Much Does It Cost to Switch to an Electric Furnace?

• Do You Need a Zoned HVAC System?

• How Much Does It Cost to Replace an Oil Furnace?

• Is an HVAC Tune-up Worth the Price? (Yes, Yes It Is)

Electric Furnace Safety Features

When choosing to install a new furnace, you may want to consider the safety of an electric versus a gas system. In general, electric furnaces are considered to be safer than their gas counterparts due to several key factors:

No Combustible Fuel

Electric furnaces do not rely on combustible fuels such as natural gas or propane for operation. This eliminates the risk of gas leaks, which can pose a significant safety hazard if left undetected.

No Carbon Monoxide Emissions

Since electric furnaces do not burn fuel, they do not produce carbon monoxide, a colorless, odorless gas that can be lethal if inhaled in high concentrations. This eliminates the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning.

No Flame or Pilot Light

Electric furnaces do not have an open flame or pilot light, reducing the risk of fire hazards associated with gas furnaces. This eliminates the potential for accidental ignition of flammable materials or gas leaks leading to fires.

Automatic Shut-off Features

Many electric furnaces are equipped with automatic shut-off features that activate in the event of overheating or other malfunctions. This helps prevent the furnace from overheating and reduces the risk of electrical fires.

Gas Furnace Safety Issues

While gas furnaces are generally safe when properly maintained and installed, they come with some inherent safety risks that homeowners should be aware of:

Risk of Gas Leaks

Gas furnaces rely on natural gas or propane as fuel, which poses a risk of gas leaks if the gas lines or connections are damaged or improperly installed. Gas leaks can lead to fires, explosions, and carbon monoxide poisoning if not detected and addressed promptly.

Carbon Monoxide Emissions

Gas furnaces produce carbon monoxide as a byproduct of combustion, which can be a safety concern if the furnace is not properly ventilated or if the ventilation system becomes blocked or malfunctioning.

Regular Maintenance Requirements

Gas furnaces require regular maintenance, including annual inspections and tune-ups, to ensure safe and efficient operation. Neglecting maintenance can lead to safety hazards.

Electric or Gas? Here’s How to Decide

It's hard to definitively say whether switching to an electric furnace will improve your utility costs because that question is highly location-dependent. Taking into account other factors — such as safety and installation prices — might help you make a well-rounded decision.